Choose Europe for Science
Europe's talent grab needs more than money
Europe's top-up grants have started to lure researchers from America, but a grant buys five years and Europe must still supply the careers.
On September 3rd 2026 the European Research Council (ERC) named 421 winners of its Starting Grants. Twenty of them were working in America, and 21 in all were based outside Europe, double the share of the year before.2 The Commission was pleased. It has been telling American scientists that Europe wants them, and here, at last, were some who had listened.
We think the numbers are real, and that they say less than Brussels hopes. Money has begun to move researchers across the Atlantic. It is not yet moving many, and it cannot do the harder part of the job, which is keeping them.
The mechanism is simple. Under the Choose Europe initiative, ERC applicants based outside Europe can ask for up to €2m on top of their grant to build a new lab or team.2 For a Starting Grant, whose standard ceiling is €1.5m over five years, the relocation bonus is larger than the grant itself.3 It is the kind of offer an academic with a grant application half written in America will read twice.
It has had some effect. In the Advanced Grants announced on June 23rd 2026, 13 of 319 winners were based outside Europe (four per cent, against four people a year earlier), nine of them in America, and seven used the extra funding.1 Applications for those grants from outside Europe rose from 44 to 164. In the Starting Grants, 169 American-based researchers applied, against 116 in the previous call.2 Ekaterina Zaharieva, the European commissioner for research, said the rise showed Choose Europe is “helping to reinforce Europe's appeal to top scientific talent worldwide”.1
Now the scale. Twenty Americans among 421 winners is about five per cent. Nobody would call it a flood. Success rates were 8.8 per cent for Starting Grants and 9.6 per cent for Advanced Grants, so these are people who beat very long odds, and many now plan to move house.12
The strongest objection is that the trend is steep, and that we are judging a rocket by its first minute. The ERC's call for 2027 Starting Grants drew 7,710 applications, up 60.4 per cent on the previous call.4 That looks like momentum. It is better read with the footnote attached: the ERC's Scientific Council also widened the eligibility windows for that call, so some of the rise is paperwork, not persuasion.4 And the money has not grown to match. The ERC has set aside €594m for about 373 grants, which is roughly one success in 20 applications.4 A bigger crowd chasing the same pot is a dearer lottery, not a better recruiting policy.
The deeper problem is the clock. A grant is a project. A five-year grant is a limited series: the first season can be excellent, but whether there is a second depends on someone else's budget. A career needs a post, and posts come from universities and the national governments that fund them, not from the ERC. Europe is also arguing about the pot itself. In a speech on October 23rd 2026 the ERC's president said the Irish presidency's negotiating proposal for Horizon Europe has almost €17bn less than the Commission's €175bn request.5 Recruits will notice that.
There is a better sign in the data, and it is not about defection. Of the 48 Synergy Grants announced on November 12th 2026, 17 involve researchers based outside Europe, and America hosts 12 projects, behind only Britain, Germany and France.6 Europe is winning partners faster than it is winning residents. That is not a failure. It is a cheaper way to stay close to American science, and one that does not wait for a lab to pack.
So we would not spend the next euro on a bigger top-up. We would spend it on permanent posts at the universities that host the winners, and on a research budget that survives negotiation. Money gets a scientist to the door. A contract that outlasts the grant gets them to unpack.
Twenty scientists have taken Europe's money. We will learn in 2031 whether they like the weather.